Prime Time Zone (EUA)

Researcher sees bubble as the only alternative to football in São Paulo

Publicado em 01 abril 2021

O football in São Paulo he has been paralyzed for two weeks because of the increase in cases and hospitalizations due to the new coronavirus (covid-19). The ban on sporting events was determined by the government of São Paulo after recommendation by the State Public Ministry. Researcher Bruno Gualano, a professor at the Faculty of Medicine of the University of São Paulo (FMUSP), however, understands that the resumption could only occur in the form of a sanitary bubble, where those involved (players, coaching staff, etc.) are totally isolated.

“In a scenario like ours, where community transmission [ da covid-19 ] remains increasingly uncontrolled, the only way you can segment any type of sector, not just sport, is to isolate it from the community. Either isolate, or stop, ”he said in an interview with Agency Brazil.

Gualano is part of the coalition Sport Covid-19, which brings together researchers from institutions such as the hospitals of the Clinics of FMUSP, Albert Einstein and do Coração, the Federal University of São Paulo (Unifesp), the Complexo Hospitalar de Niterói (RJ), the Instituto Dante Pazzanese de Cardiologia and the Center for High Sports Performance of São Paulo (NAR-SP), with support from the FPF itself. The teacher coordinated a study, released by the São Paulo State Research Support Foundation (FAPESP), based on tests carried out on 4,269 athletes who competed in the São Paulo competitions in 2020 (male and female, professional and grassroots) and 2,231 members of teams from support.

The analysis noted that the incidence of infection with the new coronavirus was 11.7% (501) among athletes and 7% (161) among staff members. The last group, which brings together managers and members of the technical committee, where age is higher and health conditions vary widely, is the one that registered the most serious cases. Among them, a death.

According to Gualano, the percentage is equivalent to the incidence in frontline health professionals in the pandemic. In note, the FPF Medical Committee maintained that the comparison “is scientifically incorrect, as surely frequent testing in all athletes has enabled a greater number of diagnoses, mainly because they are asymptomatic” and that football “performs more tests” than most segments of society.

“The comparison we made is based on science,” says Gualano. “The frontline health professionals were tested by serology, so there is no need to talk about any cases not detected by the PCR exam that takes place in football. PCR is not the most sensitive instrument to detect exposures to the disease, since it is sensitive to a short period of time, three to ten days. Serological surveys are more informative in this regard ”, he adds.

The researcher understands that the performance of more than 30,000 tests (precisely 31,632, according to the FPF, between July 1 and December 31, 2020) shows that the application of the protocol in the sports environment has been fulfilled. The problem, according to him, is outside the football environment.

“The positivity [ considerando o total de testes realizados ] was low, which means that it was properly tested, this is important. The overriding factor for the high number of infections is the lack of control of community transmission. The players followed the protocol in the sporting environment. Outside of it, there was no control whatsoever. We did not know where these players would meet at night, where they would go out to dinner, how many people lived together, if they cleaned themselves, if the distance was fulfilled. The protocol didn’t go that far, ”argues Gualano.

The survey also compared the incidence of covid-19 in São Paulo soccer athletes with other countries, and found that the percentage surpassed leagues such as Qatar (4%) and the Bundesliga, first division of the German Championship (0.6%). The note from the FPF Medical Committee understands that, “from a scientific point of view”, such a correlation would be unfeasible, “after all, there are huge differences between countries / leagues”, such as the characteristics of protocols, the period of analysis, the social characteristics and the stage of the pandemic.

“When we do a study like ours, on the incidence of infection in a restricted population, the objective is to compare it with other scenarios, to know at what stage we are in epidemic control. What we compared, basically, was the opening of football with other countries, which had scientifically published data. Of course, there are peculiarities in the epidemic scenario of the various countries, more referring to community transmission and less regarding protocols. Precisely by comparison with other scenarios, we are able to reach the conclusion that the opening of sport in an unmitigated environment, with high community transmission, requires stricter transmission control measures ”, concludes the FMUSP professor.

Football games are banned in São Paulo until at least April 12, the day after the end of the Emergency Phase, the most restrictive of the São Paulo Plan, to fight covid-19. The FPF met, at the beginning of the week, with the Public Prosecutor’s Office to present a new protocol, more demanding, to try to make the resumption of competition possible before the 11th. Among the measures, are the adoption of bubbles for concentration of athletes and technical commissions, with testing in the 24 hours before entering the isolation, PCR exams before and after each game and removal of the athlete and tracking contacts in case of positive results. The organization has stated that the state A1 (first division) Series will be completed on the scheduled date, on May 23.

Essa notícia também repercutiu nos veículos:
O Globo O Globo online O Globo online O Estado de S. Paulo Estadã Correio Popular (Campinas, SP) UOL UOL Portal R7 Folha de Pernambuco online O Globo online Portal R7 CNN (Brasil) IstoÉ online Yahoo! Yahoo! TV Cultura TV UOL Yahoo! UOL UOL Diário do Grande ABC online Agência Brasil BOL Portal Exame IstoÉ online IstoÉ Dinheiro online UOL TV Globo Folha de S. Paulo Agora São Paulo Folha de S. Paulo Cruzeiro do Sul Jornal Primeira Página Portal R7 CBN Notícias Estadã Plantão News (MT) Terra Blog do Professor Rafael Porcari MSN (Brasil) Blog Saúde e Dicas Bahia Jornal Verguia Novo Cantu Notícias Diário em Foco TV Diário de Alagoas Pelo Mundo DF Xingu 230 Portal Curiúva Laranjeiras News Gazeta do Dia (Sorriso, MT) Itaberaba em Foco Folha de Sabará online Coluna Supinando Jornal do Commercio (PE) online Galileu online A Crítica (AM) online Time 24 News (EUA) Blog do Professor Rafael Porcari Globo Esporte online Baiano News Recôncavo no Ar Rádio Cultura FM 101,7 Rádio Nova Onda FM 87,9 Folha do Estado da Bahia (Feira de Santana, BA) online Rádio Cidade Nova FM 104,9 Rede Agora de Notícias Central Brasil Notícias ZUG MSN (Brasil) Rádio Itatiaia 610 AM | 95,7 FM Revista Cenarium online Folha do Estado da Bahia (Feira de Santana, BA) online Tudo Timão OneFootball (Brasil) ESPN Brasil Boa Informação Portal Atualizado Portal Agora Notícias Portal Manhumirim São Bento em Foco O Ribanense Jornal do Oeste (Toledo, PR) online Diário do Sudoeste (Pato Branco, PR) online Notícias ao Minuto (Brasil) Folha Vitória online Tribuna de Petrópolis online Barulho Curitiba Rádio Metropolitana 98.5 FM Planeta online Ler News Yahoo! Finanças O Curioso do Futebol Consecti - Conselho Nacional de Secretários Estaduais para Assuntos de CT&I Portal Thathi Head Topics (Colômbia) Central do Timão Saiba de Tudo Fatos Locais Relata Bahia Debate Paraíba Tech Break Doutor Jairo Bouer Diário de S.Paulo online Leitura do Povo Cuiabano News UmDois Esportes Pequi FM 87,5 Yahoo! Vida e Estilo Yahoo! Finanças MSN (Brasil) Jornal de Jundiaí online Globo Esporte online Extra (Rio de Janeiro, RJ) online InfoHealth Seu Expediente Jornais Virtuais Portal Vermelho Atlântica News Jornal da USP online Blog do Malia Meu Timão Ludopédio Marcondes Brito Jornal de Barretos online Metro Jornal online São Paulo Tricolor Dikajob Visão Regional FPF - Federação Paulista de Futebol Portal 90 min Head Topics (Colômbia) Saúde em Tela Esquerda Marxista Núcleo Luciano Lepera Ler News Jornal de Barretos Verdão Web Doble Amarilla (Argentina) Brazilian Report Portal RG Cidade Esportes Central do Timão OneFootball (Brasil) Ciência na rua Emergência 190 Paracatu News Jornal de Jundiaí online Gazeta Brazilian News (EUA) online Tudo em Dia Acontece no RS Portal Agora Notícias Repórter Maceió São Bento em Foco Nitro News Brasil Perfil (Brasil) Índices Bovespa Times do Rio A Tribuna (Santos, SP) online Portal GRNews Dom Total Tribuna União 2A+ Farma DF Manchetes Portal NBO Jornal Fogo Cruzado DF Novo Cantu Notícias Douranews Portal Manhumirim Mix Vale Folha do MS (MS) Plano de Vida Tá no site Rio Brilhante News Jornal Ponta Grossa Esportesnet Verguia Tarobá News Noroeste Acontece online Itamarati News O Povo online Jornal de Piracicaba online A Cidade On (São Carlos, SP) Edição MS Diário de Votuporanga online Dinheiro Rural online TV Caeté Pelo Mundo DF Rede Interativa Fatos Locais Xingu 230 Coluna Supinando Tribuna MS O Ribanense Gazeta do Dia (Sorriso, MT) Folha de Sabará online Bahia Jornal Galáticos Online Diário Popular IPTV Jornal Roraima Hoje Bom Dia Cidade Notícias Portal Rondônia Super Rádio Tupi FM 96,5 RP10 Portal Morada India Education Diary (Índia) Cruzeiro do Sul online Jornal Z Norte online MundoBit Coisas da Vida Empresas S/A Band Cenário Minas Portal Fator Brasil Falando de Gestão Jornalismo 24 Horas Esporte Ágil Duna Press (Noruega, em português) Por Dentro de Minas Portal Paraná Empresarial Olho No Esporte MT Por Dentro do Coronavírus Portal de Finanças Marcas e Mercados APIMEC - Associação dos Analistas e Profissionais de Investimento do Mercado de Capitais Leia Notícias Região Noroeste Acre ao Vivo Cidade Notícia Inforbrnet O Mariliense Poliarquia Jornal Primeira Página online Hortêncio FM 87.5 Momento MT A Cidade On (Campinas, SP) Referência Brasil Repórter1 Giro de Notícia Hora 1 MT Cardoso & Advogados Associados Portal Bacabal Jornal A Cidade (Ponta Porã, MS) Notícia SAJ TV Brusque Agora Região Jardim Informa DF Imparcial Jornal Tabloide (Ourinhos, SP) Rômulo de Oliveira Martins: Advocacia e Assessoria Jurídica Toni Rodrigues Jornal A Voz dos Municipios Fluminenses online Portal VDL Oeste 360 Alagoas Agora online Araguaia Urgente Portal RB1 Notícias Garanhuns Notícias BandSports Blog do Paulinho (Venezuela) Diário Regional (Juiz de Fora, MG) online Tribuna Ribeirão online ISN Portal RCI Araraquara Blog do Paulinho São Paulo FM Tudo é Espanto Jornal de Barretos online India Education Diary (Índia) Revista Questão de Ciência O Âncora Portal Space Portal Conceição Verdade Canoa Notícias MS em Movimento Portal Rondon Brazil News - SPFC.Net Garanhuns Notícias Altos Papos Conexão Regional Circuito D Extra News MS Portal G86 TV Interbam Osvaldo Batista Sert news Maranhão em Pauta NB Notícias Oeste 360 Folha Impacto Jornal A Voz do Povo online (Uberlândia, MG) Alagoas Agora online Geral Notícias Rádio Cidade 87,9 FM Agora Região Jornal A Trombeta online ABN - Academia Brasileira de Neurologia Plantão Amazonense Jornal da Manhã (Marília, SP) Esporte News Mundo Jornal de Barretos Tech Break Folha da Minha Sampa Circulando Aqui Conecta Oeste Carta Campinas Rede Brasil Atual Brazil News (Portugal) RN Hoje Football Addict (Brasil) Mundo Lusíada Jornal Português TV Brusque Campo Belo em Foco Portal Brasileira Giro Notícias Goiás Folha da Minha Sampa Campo Belo em Foco Norte Piauí Blog 3 Poderes Blog 3 Poderes OffNews O Melhor da Cidade O Melhor da Cidade MSN en Español Rádio Uau InforBahia MS Aqui News Notícias da Sua Cidade Metropolitana MS Grava News - Jornal de Alfenas Grava News - Jornal de Alfenas Portal Chapada Grande Portal Chapada Grande Rádio Água Clara News MA217 MA217 SouPVH SoundCloud (Alemanha) Minha Pará de Minas Minha Pará de Minas Head Topics (Brasil) Alerta Municípios Voz do Piauí Top Morena Agência Trampo Lucas em foco Blog O Correspondente BF News Capital BF News Capital Lucas em foco Conexão Na Cidade Cidade Notícia APAN - Associação Paulista de Neurologia Diário Caiobá Jornal Desperta Cidade Conexão Na Cidade Mirante da Bocaina MaisAM Diário de Três Lagoas Portal Legalzona Portal VDL Penha News Radar MT Rádio Atalaia FM 87,9 Oficial News Portal Paripiranguense Saber Atualizado O Melhor do Futebol Radar MT Rádio Atalaia FM 87,9 Rádio Cristalina FM 103.7 Portal G86 Penha News Tribuna Press Cronistas MS Bacana News Mais Notícias MS HZM - Instituto de Ensino e Pesquisa Diário Piauiense Debate Esportivo Jornal Cidade (Barreiras, BA) online GG Notícias O Antagonista Porto Murtinho Notícias Toni Rodrigues RV News Guia Valença Dia a Dia Nordeste Rádio Peão Brasil Pra onde vai São Paulo? Esporte Notícia Mychooice REEN - Rede de Entretenimento, Esportes e Notícias Rádio Leme FM Brasil de Olho Ponta Porã Digital Cabreúva Online Giro 7 Rio Brilhante News A Voz dos Municípios (Laranjeiras, Sergipe) online Página de Polícia Poder e Notícia Bom Dia Cidade Notícias Grupo News Paraná Jornal A Cidade (Ponta Porã, MS) LauroCITY MaisAM Portal Afunilados Acre ao Vivo Diário D4 Notícias Porto Estrela News Alvo Notícias Collie River Online News (Austrália) LauroCITY Diário D4 Notícias Oeste Ao Vivo Maranhão em Pauta Rádio Leme FM Relata Bahia Cabreúva Online Brasil de Olho TV Interbam Grupo News Paraná Giro 7 Portal Afunilados Poder e Notícia REEN - Rede de Entretenimento, Esportes e Notícias