Olhar Digital

Manaus: almost a third of Covid-19 cases were reinfected by the P.1 variant in 2021

Publicado em 18 maio 2021

Por Kaique Lima

A study carried out by University of São Paulo (USP) in partnership with Oxford University, in England, found that about a third of the Covid-19 cases detected in Manaus since January were reinfections by the variant P.1.

According to the article, in October 2020, 76% of residents had already been exposed to SARS-CoV-2, which is the Covid-19 virus. In the second wave faced by the capital of Amazonas, 87% of the cases would have been caused by the P.1 variant.

The work was led by researchers Ester Sabino, from USP, and Nuno Faria, from Oxford University. In all, blood samples were analyzed from 238 blood donors that met specific criteria, such as having made three or more donations, at least one of them before July 2020 and a second between January and March 2021.

In the article, which has yet to be peer-reviewed, the group describes how antibodies and immune system molecules reacted to antibody tests on each of the samples. After that, they determined which of the volunteers could have been more than once based on the strength of the immune response presented by them.

"Our data suggest that reinfection by P.1 is more common and more frequent than had been detected by traditional methods of genomic, molecular and epidemiological surveillance of clinical cases," say the scientists in the study.

Previous study received criticism

However, this high estimate of the prevalence of Covid-19 as measured by the group has attracted some criticism from scientists in Manaus. The main one is that this proportion of infected (87%), would represent that Manaus has achieved group immunity against Covid-19.

These figures were even used by politicians and traders in the region as an argument to call for the reopening of trade. Flexibilization was carried out and ended up resulting in a outbreak of the disease in the city, when the health system collapsed and even oxygen was lacking for patients.

It was in this context that the P.1 variant expanded its circulation, but, for some epidemiologists, this was not the only reason for the dimension of the second wave. In addition, for them, blood donors are not a population that provides a reliable diagnosis of the spread of the disease.

“Donors have an age group that does not represent the whole of Manaus, excluding children and the elderly. And, in addition, those who donate blood in general are from the middle or lower class, and this also restricts the population analyzed ”, said the epidemiologist at Fiocruz Manaus, Marcus Lacerda, newspaper The Globe.

Another point of attention is the fact that people who have not yet had antibodies against Covid-19 as positive diagnoses. “The test had a determined sensitivity, and they ended up reducing it. This resulted in a positive group of people who probably did not have IgG, that is, did not have an antibody against Covid-19 ”, says Lacerda.

USP / Oxford team responses

The first study led by Sabino and Faria on the topic was published in the journal Science in 2020 and received some criticism from peers, which have been answered since then. Ester Sabino says that due care was taken to avoid distortions in the study results.

“We discounted the false positive rate. We did, yes, several tests using several different cuts manufacturers. They all hit the same value. We made other models to correct the drop in antibodies and hit the same estimate, ”she said.

On the issue of collective immunity, Sabino says that the study was misinterpreted outside the scientific community, in addition to that he never said that the epidemic was controlled in Manaus. “Communicating science is very difficult. In fact, our work came out as an “attack rate”, and not as “herd immunity” “, said the researcher.

“I could have changed the title. At the time, I didn't think people would understand it by looking at the title that way. But I don't think what we did is wrong. This is not saying that the epidemic is over at any time, and it is very clear in our text ”, he reinforces.

"I think it would be very wrong if I did not tell the population that we had found such a high prevalence in Manaus, because now it gives the context to know that they can catch Covid-19 a third time too," she concluded.

Essa notícia também repercutiu nos veículos:
Folha de S. Paulo Portal R7 UOL Folha de Pernambuco online Estadã Galileu online O Globo online Correio Braziliense online Yahoo! Folha de S. Paulo Gazeta do Povo online (PR) Quimiweb IG A Crítica (AM) online Portal Você Online Vocativo Tangará em Foco O Bom da Notícia Portal MT Notícia em Foco MT Portal Lapada Lapada Voz MT O Documento online Portal Mato Grosso Bem Notícias Giro Marília O Atual Revista Cenarium online Revista Cenarium online Dom Total 18 Horas NE10 Periferia Ciencia (Argentina) Portal do Marcos Santos Jornal A Voz do Povo online (Uberlândia, MG) Xingu 230 Portal Curiúva Jaguariaíva em Foco Laranjeiras News Gazeta do Dia (Sorriso, MT) Folha de Sabará online Itaberaba em Foco Campo Belo em Foco Blog do HP Portal VDL Bahia Jornal Acontece no RS O Repórter Regional online Jornal Ponta Grossa Novo Cantu Notícias TV Diário de Alagoas Circulando Aqui Antenados Revista Metropolitana Radar MT NB Notícias Mustach Portal Tá Ligado! Rádio Saj Net Verguia Rio Brilhante News Planeta online Revista Cenarium online SB 24 horas Portal da Enfermagem Brasil123 O Acre Agora Metrópoles 24 Brasil Portal Amazônia Blog Saúde e Dicas Bom Dia Cidade Notícias Coluna Supinando Portal Atualizado Extra News MS Esplanada News Portal Agora Notícias Amazônia Sem Fronteira Araraquara24horas São Bento em Foco Diversidade Amazônica D24AM MSN (Brasil) Terra FOCEP Brasil Blog A Crítica MSN (Brasil) Veja Saúde online Pelo Mundo DF Portal Marcela Rosa Portal Altônia Debate Paraíba Rosário News Portal da Feira MSN (Brasil) ClickPB Real Time 1 Portal Norte de Notícias Noticias RTV (Espanha) The World News (Ucrânia/Brasil) Saber Atualizado Portal de Notícias Virou Manchete Portal Tucumã Outras Vias Estado Político Digital Web Brasil Mediawork Saense Índices Bovespa Canaltech Portal Gongogi Saúde em Tela Portal Correio Amazonense São Paulo FM Riacho Notícias Tribuna Paulista Folha da Minha Sampa MA217 O Santarritense Digital Portal Now Portal O Sertão ABN - Academia Brasileira de Neurologia Alvo Notícias Amazônia Post J1 Notícias Portal Onda Sul 100,7 FM Portalqn Poder360 ORC – Orlândia Rádio Clube Ltda – AM 1240 Khz Única News Giro Notícias Goiás Jornal A Cidade (Ponta Porã, MS) Portal Brasileira TV Brusque Blog 3 Poderes Visão News TV & VC? Conexão MT O Melhor da Cidade O Servidor Público RBN 94,3 FM Rádio Uau InforBahia Notícias da Sua Cidade MS Aqui News Metropolitana MS Jundiaí Online Jornal Um Só Corpo Grava News - Jornal de Alfenas Imperlove Portal Chapada Grande Cidade Notícia SouPVH Momento MT Clique Piripiri Uiraú Vírus News A Tarde (BA) online Bom dia Paraiba Agora Região Minha Pará de Minas Revista Fórum online Acre ao Vivo BF News Capital Relato News Garanhuns Notícias Porto Estrela News Lucas em foco Piracuruca News MaisAM Conexão Na Cidade Diário Caiobá Oficial News Portal Paripiranguense Portal do Trairi Portal G86 Penha News Rádio Atalaia FM 87,9 Giro Marília LauroCITY Grupo News Paraná Maranhão em Pauta Oeste 360 Osvaldo Batista Poder e Notícia A Voz dos Municípios (Laranjeiras, Sergipe) online Página de Polícia Cabreúva Online Ponta Porã Digital Diário D4 Notícias Porto Murtinho Notícias TV Interbam Brasil de Olho Alagoas Agora online Portal Afunilados Bahia Revista Giro 7 Dia a Dia Nordeste RV News Toni Rodrigues Rádio Leme FM REEN - Rede de Entretenimento, Esportes e Notícias