Enciclopédia Virtual

Coronavirus: collective immunity can be achieved with up to 20% infected

Publicado em 28 julho 2020

Por Enciclopédia Virtual

A study published on July 24 on the medRxiv platform, still without peer review, estimates that the collective immunity threshold to the new coronavirus (SARS-CoV-2), also known as herd immunity, can be achieved in a given region if somewhere between 10% and 20% of the population is infected.

If the projection is confirmed in practice, the developments tend to be positive in two aspects. First, because it means that there is little risk of a second overwhelming wave of the pandemic in countries that have adopted measures to contain the spread of COVID-19 and today they are already registering a drop in the number of new cases.

Secondly, because it indicates that it is possible for a city, state or country to reach the threshold of collective immunity even though it has adopted measures of social distance that help to prevent the collapse of the health system and to minimize the number of deaths.

“Our model shows that there is no need to sacrifice the population by letting it circulate freely for collective immunity to develop. On the other hand, it suggests that there is also no need to keep people at home for many, many months, until a vaccine is approved ”, says Portuguese biomathematician Gabriela Gomes to Agência FAPESP, currently at the University of Strathclyde, in the United Kingdom.

The mathematical model to which the researcher refers was developed in collaboration with scientists from Brazil, Portugal and the United Kingdom. Among the co-authors of the article are Marcelo Urbano Ferreira, professor at the Institute of Biomedical Sciences at the University of São Paulo (ICB-USP) and his doctoral student Rodrigo Corder.

“We have been working together with Gabriela Gomes for some years using this approach to describe the dynamics of malaria transmission in the Brazilian Amazon, with support from FAPESP (São Paulo State Research Support Foundation).

She had also done some studies on tuberculosis. The model we use is different from the others, as it takes into account the fact that the risk of contracting a certain disease varies from person to person, ”says Ferreira.

As Gomes explains, the factors that influence an individual’s risk of contracting COVID-19, for example, can be divided into two categories. In one of them are the biological ones, such as genetics, nutrition and immunity. The other includes behavioral factors, which determine the level of contact with other people that each of us has in our daily lives.

“This has to do with the type of occupation, the place of residence, the means of transportation and even the personality profile. A person who prefers to stay at home reading a book has a lower risk of being exposed to the virus than someone who goes out very often and has relationships with many people ”, says the researcher.

According to Gomes, the models that estimated the threshold of immunity to SARS-CoV-2 varying between 50% and 70% consider that the risk of infection is the same for all individuals.

“We have seen that, in the case of COVID-19, the greater the degree of heterogeneity in the population, the lower the threshold for group immunity becomes,” says Gomes.


Measuring in each individual of a population each of the factors that influence the susceptibility to contract the new coronavirus and then calculating what would be the so-called “coefficient of variation” – a key parameter of the model described in the article – would be unviable. For this reason, the researchers chose to take the path backwards.

“We know that if we change the variation coefficient, there is an impact on the epidemic curve projected by the model. We then decided to do the reverse: we used the epidemic curve of countries where the epidemic was already at an advanced stage to calculate the coefficient of variation ”, explains Gomes.

The most recent version of the work is based on incidence data (number of new daily cases) from Belgium, England, Spain and Portugal. “We intend to study data from Brazil and the United States soon, where the epidemic is still evolving,” says the researcher.

According to the authors, although the coefficient of variation is different in each country, in general, the collective immunity threshold tends to remain between 10% and 20% and this is extremely relevant for the formulation of public policies.

“In places where the collective immunity threshold has already been reached, the trend is that the number of new cases will continue to fall even if the economy is reopened. But if the distance measures are relaxed before collective immunity is achieved, cases are likely to rise again and managers should be aware, ”says Corder. “Conceptually, after reaching collective immunity, transmission tends to be prolonged if control measures are removed quickly”, he warns

According to Gomes’ report, in Portugal it is possible to observe two different situations. The northern region, where the virus entered the country, was much more impacted at the beginning of the pandemic and now, even with the economy reopened, the number of new cases remains falling. In the south, where the capital Lisbon is located, the cases follow an upward trend.

“For the time being there are localized outbreaks, in Lisbon neighborhoods, which are being contained locally through testing and isolating infected people. People were only released to return to work in Portugal after taking tests ”, says the researcher.

A partially similar situation occurs in Brazil. The region of Manaus (AM), in the North, apparently reached the peak of the epidemic curve in May, when the health system collapsed. After that, the number of new cases has fallen even with the open economy and schools resuming face-to-face activities Serological studies have indicated that in cities like Manaus and Belém, in Pará, more than 10% of the population already has antibodies against the new coronavirus.

The South region, which registered a small number of infections at the beginning of the epidemic and where the seroprevalence rate in the population was around 1% in May, has registered an increase in the number of new cases as activities are resumed. . Unlike Portugal, investment in testing and tracking infected people in Brazil still falls short of what is considered ideal

As the authors of the article point out, the fact that the collective immunity threshold is lower than initially planned does not diminish the importance of public health measures to contain the spread of the virus and reduce the number of deaths.

“If any manager defends collective immunity as a public policy, he is wrong. Control measures are important to avoid overloading the health system. But the new understanding of the transmission dynamics of COVID-19 that our model brings points to a more optimistic scenario ”, says Corder.

In Gomes’ assessment, adherence to isolation measures tends to be greater if people know that sacrifice will be necessary for a shorter period. “When we say that the epidemic will only be overcome when the vaccine arrives, people start to think about breaking the rules, as they can no longer handle a life that is not so sociable, with so many restrictions”, he says.

Next steps. Feeding the model with real-world data is the best way to make your simulations and estimates more realistic. With this objective, Ferreira intends to test in a field study in Acre two assumptions used in the group’s calculations: the disease detection index (the difference between the actual number of infected and the number of diagnosed cases) and the duration of the disease. immunity against SARS-CoV-2.

“At work, we consider that around 10% of real cases are detected by health services and that immunity against the virus lasts for at least one year. We will see if this is confirmed in a population that we have been following for some years in the city of Mâncio Lima ”, says the researcher.

The ICB-USP group has been carrying out household surveys every six months with a sample of the population of the Acriana city located on the border with Peru. In addition to applying questionnaires, the researchers collect blood samples. The idea is to monitor how SARS-CoV-2 seroprevalence evolves in this population over the next year and to observe how long antibodies can be detected in the blood. The work is supported by Fapesp.

Essa notícia também repercutiu nos veículos:
TV Cultura IstoÉ Dinheiro online IstoÉ online Diário do Grande ABC online BOL UOL Estado de Minas online Correio Braziliense online UOL Estadã Portal R7 Portal Exame SBT Interior Cruzeiro do Sul Portal R7 Yahoo! Portal R7 O Povo Jornal Primeira Página Yahoo! Yahoo! TV Brasil EBC Rádios O Globo online O Globo O Globo online Notícias Agrícolas Folha Vitória online Folha de Valinhos online Rede Massa SBT Jornal da Cidade (Bauru, SP) online Aqui Notícias online Meon Tribuna do Sertão Diário de Notícias online Mix Vale Zero Hora online Mercado News Bem Paraná online Correio do Papagaio online FasterNet Dinheiro Rural online MidiaMax CGN Tribuna do Agreste A Crítica (MS) online Cidade Verde Repórter Diário HiperNotícias Jornal do Commercio (PE) online ES360 Santa Portal Portal do Holanda O Liberal (PA) online Portal Banda B NH TV Guarulhosweb TN Online Rádio Itatiaia 610 AM | 95,7 FM A Tribuna (ES) online Notícias do Dia O Tempo online O Tempo (Contagem, MG) online Super Notícia 91,7 FM Meia Hora online O Dia (Rio de Janeiro, RJ) online Jornal do Comércio (RS) online Press From Brasil (EUA) Terra MSN (Brasil) Blog Martins 24h Head Topics (Brasil) Correio do Estado da Bahia (Blog) Blog Henrique Barbosa O Liberal (Americana, SP) online A Gazeta (ES) online Época Negócios online Correio Popular (Campinas, SP) online Portal Comunica AM! Portal GMC Online Jornal Folha de Videira online Central das Notícias Luciano Vale Martins em Pauta Blog do BG Blog Lidianópolis News São Miguel para Todos Saber Atualizado Portal do Zacarias Jornal O Diário (RJ) online Metrópole MS Jornais Virtuais Gazeta de Alagoas online Bixo Furioso FoxBe Itaquiraí em Foco RIC Mais Portal Cada Segundo Portal O Sertão Prime News Mais Ceará Up Varginha Cidades na Net Jornal Opção (Goiânia, GO) online Central das Notícias Planeta online Portal Prudentino Portal da Enfermagem Revista Amazônia São Carlos em Rede Jornal Alerta Blog do Gustavo Negreiros Região Noroeste Portal N10 Tribuna do Interior online Le Portale Expresso PB Oeste em Foco online Portal S1 Portal da Cidade (Pontal do Paraná, PR) The World News (Ucrânia/Brasil) Porto Alegre 24 Horas Jornal de Itatiba online Brasil 2 Pontos Le Gran Capital News Jornal da Ciência online Espaço Ecológico no Ar Jornal GGN Blog A Crítica Atemporal RedePRESS Altair Tavares Programa InfoSalud (Argentina) Canaltech O Potiguar Mundo e Meio Pirajuí Rádio Clube Tech Na Net Blog Saúde e Dicas Blog Saúde e Dicas Blog Jornal da Mulher BonitoNet Roberto Crispim Head Topics (Brasil) MT HOJE Jornal Primeira Página online Jornal da Cidade - Bauru Algomais online O Diário do Vale Portal Saúde no Ar Web24 News Dom Total Por Dentro de Tudo Farmacêutico Márcio Antoniassi O Vale online O Vale online Jornal Fogo Cruzado DF Portal Vermelho Head Topics (Reino Unido) Rádio Jornal Parintins Amazonas Claudio Tognolli PB Agora Parlamento PB Folha de Dourados online O Vale online Bastidores da Política PB Blog do BG Recôncavo no Ar Forte na Notícia Paraíba Notícia Blog do Robson Pires Jequié Repórter - Blog de Wilson Novaes Blog de Daltro Emerenciano Ipiaú online Nova Mais Blog de Olho no Assú